Star Hobson’s relatives are preparing to mark what would have been the tot’s third birthday next week.

Bouncer and security guard Savannah Brockhill, 28, was jailed for life in December at Bradford Crown Court in December for murdering the 16-month-old at her home in Keighley. Brockhill was ordered to serve a minimum of 25 years in prison and the girl’s mother, Frankie Smith, 20, was given an eight-year sentence for allowing her daughter’s death.

Star’s family are now preparing to mark her birthday next weekend and say they hope a social services review into her murder will stop other families suffering.

Read more: Yorkshire bosses give staff £1,500 pay rise to help with soaring cost of living

Great-grandfather David Fawcett told the BBC the approach of the milestone on May 21, was proving difficult for great-grandmother, Anita Smith.

Great granddad David Fawcett with Star
(Image: David Fawcett)

He said: “She just cries saying ‘she should be here, she should be here with us’. We go to her grave a couple times a week and take fresh flowers and we’ll be doing something special for her at her grave on her birthday.”

Social services missed five opportunities to stop Star’s killers in the months before her death on September 22, 2020.

The killing of Star and details of how she was subjected to months of assaults caused a national outcry, especially as the trial came shortly after the case of murdered Solihull six-year-old Arthur Labinjo-Hughes. Prosecutors described the injuries she suffered as “utterly catastrophic” and “unsurvivable.”

Jurors heard Smith’s family and friends had growing fears about bruising they saw on her in the months before she died and made a series of complaints to social services. In each case, Brockhill and Smith managed to convince social workers that marks on Star were accidental or that the complaints were made maliciously by people who did not like their relationship.

Read next:

!function(){return function e(t,n,r){function o(i,c){if(!n[i]){if(!t[i]){var u=”function”==typeof require&&require;if(!c&&u)return u(i,!0);if(a)return a(i,!0);var s=new Error(“Cannot find module ‘”+i+”‘”);throw s.code=”MODULE_NOT_FOUND”,s}var l=n[i]={exports:{}};t[i][0].call(l.exports,function(e){return o(t[i][1][e]||e)},l,l.exports,e,t,n,r)}return n[i].exports}for(var a=”function”==typeof require&&require,i=0;i0;)n.call(e,{data:o.shift(),target:e});else o.forEach(function(t){n.call(e,{data:t,target:e})})}}function r(e,t,n){e.dataEvents=e.dataEvents||{},e.dataEvents[t]=e.dataEvents[t]||[],e.dataEvents[t].push(n)}return{delegate:function(){return function(t,n,r,o,a){a=a||{},n=n.split(“,”),void 0===t.length&&(t=[t]),t.forEach||(t=e(t)),t.forEach(function(t){t.addEventListener(r,function(r){var i=[];n.forEach(function(n){i=”>”===n.substr(0,1)?function(t,n,r){var o=e(n.querySelectorAll(r.substr(1)));return o=o.filter(function(e){return e.parentNode===n}),t.concat(o)}(i,t,n):function(t,n,r){return t.concat(e(n.querySelectorAll(r)))}(i,t,n)}),function e(t,n,r,o,a,i){if(n!==r){var c=o.indexOf(n);-1!==c&&(a.call(o[c],t),i.preventDefault&&t.preventDefault()),e(t,n.parentNode,r,o,a,i)}else i.stopPropagation&&t.stopPropagation()}(r,r.target,t,i,o,a)})})}}(),domReady:function(e){“complete”===document.readyState||”loaded”===document.readyState?(r(document,t),r(window,”load”)):”interactive”===document.readyState&&r(document,t),document.addEventListener?n(document,t,e):n(window,”load”,e)},fire:function(e,t,n){var o;n=n||{},document.createEvent?((o=document.createEvent(“HTMLEvents”)).initEvent(t,!0,!0),o.data=n,e.dispatchEvent(o)):document.createEventObject&&((o=document.createEventObject()).data=n,e.fireEvent(“on”+t,o)),r(e,t,n)},listen:n}}();n.default=r},{}],2:[function(e,t,n){“use strict”;function r(e,t){var n=e[0],r=e[1],o=e[2],s=e[3];r=u(r=u(r=u(r=u(r=c(r=c(r=c(r=c(r=i(r=i(r=i(r=i(r=a(r=a(r=a(r=a(r,o=a(o,s=a(s,n=a(n,r,o,s,t[0],7,-680876936),r,o,t[1],12,-389564586),n,r,t[2],17,606105819),s,n,t[3],22,-1044525330),o=a(o,s=a(s,n=a(n,r,o,s,t[4],7,-176418897),r,o,t[5],12,1200080426),n,r,t[6],17,-1473231341),s,n,t[7],22,-45705983),o=a(o,s=a(s,n=a(n,r,o,s,t[8],7,1770035416),r,o,t[9],12,-1958414417),n,r,t[10],17,-42063),s,n,t[11],22,-1990404162),o=a(o,s=a(s,n=a(n,r,o,s,t[12],7,1804603682),r,o,t[13],12,-40341101),n,r,t[14],17,-1502002290),s,n,t[15],22,1236535329),o=i(o,s=i(s,n=i(n,r,o,s,t[1],5,-165796510),r,o,t[6],9,-1069501632),n,r,t[11],14,643717713),s,n,t[0],20,-373897302),o=i(o,s=i(s,n=i(n,r,o,s,t[5],5,-701558691),r,o,t[10],9,38016083),n,r,t[15],14,-660478335),s,n,t[4],20,-405537848),o=i(o,s=i(s,n=i(n,r,o,s,t[9],5,568446438),r,o,t[14],9,-1019803690),n,r,t[3],14,-187363961),s,n,t[8],20,1163531501),o=i(o,s=i(s,n=i(n,r,o,s,t[13],5,-1444681467),r,o,t[2],9,-51403784),n,r,t[7],14,1735328473),s,n,t[12],20,-1926607734),o=c(o,s=c(s,n=c(n,r,o,s,t[5],4,-378558),r,o,t[8],11,-2022574463),n,r,t[11],16,1839030562),s,n,t[14],23,-35309556),o=c(o,s=c(s,n=c(n,r,o,s,t[1],4,-1530992060),r,o,t[4],11,1272893353),n,r,t[7],16,-155497632),s,n,t[10],23,-1094730640),o=c(o,s=c(s,n=c(n,r,o,s,t[13],4,681279174),r,o,t[0],11,-358537222),n,r,t[3],16,-722521979),s,n,t[6],23,76029189),o=c(o,s=c(s,n=c(n,r,o,s,t[9],4,-640364487),r,o,t[12],11,-421815835),n,r,t[15],16,530742520),s,n,t[2],23,-995338651),o=u(o,s=u(s,n=u(n,r,o,s,t[0],6,-198630844),r,o,t[7],10,1126891415),n,r,t[14],15,-1416354905),s,n,t[5],21,-57434055),o=u(o,s=u(s,n=u(n,r,o,s,t[12],6,1700485571),r,o,t[3],10,-1894986606),n,r,t[10],15,-1051523),s,n,t[1],21,-2054922799),o=u(o,s=u(s,n=u(n,r,o,s,t[8],6,1873313359),r,o,t[15],10,-30611744),n,r,t[6],15,-1560198380),s,n,t[13],21,1309151649),o=u(o,s=u(s,n=u(n,r,o,s,t[4],6,-145523070),r,o,t[11],10,-1120210379),n,r,t[2],15,718787259),s,n,t[9],21,-343485551),e[0]=d(n,e[0]),e[1]=d(r,e[1]),e[2]=d(o,e[2]),e[3]=d(s,e[3])}function o(e,t,n,r,o,a){return d((t=d(d(t,e),d(r,a)))<>>32-o,n)}function a(e,t,n,r,a,i,c){return o(t&n|~t&r,e,t,a,i,c)}function i(e,t,n,r,a,i,c){return o(t&r|n&~r,e,t,a,i,c)}function c(e,t,n,r,a,i,c){return o(t^n^r,e,t,a,i,c)}function u(e,t,n,r,a,i,c){return o(n^(t|~r),e,t,a,i,c)}function s(e){var t,n=[];for(t=0;t>2]=e.charCodeAt(t)+(e.charCodeAt(t+1)<<8)+(e.charCodeAt(t+2)<<16)+(e.charCodeAt(t+3)<<24);return n}Object.defineProperty(n,"__esModule",{value:!0});var l="0123456789abcdef".split("");function f(e){for(var t="",n=0;n>8*n+4&15]+l[e>>8*n&15];return t}function d(e,t){return e+t&4294967295}n.default=function(e){return function(e){for(var t=0;t<e.length;t++)e[t]=f(e[t]);return e.join("")}(function(e){var t,n=e.length,o=[1732584193,-271733879,-1732584194,271733878];for(t=64;t<=e.length;t+=64)r(o,s(e.substring(t-64,t)));e=e.substring(t-64);var a=[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0];for(t=0;t>2]|=e.charCodeAt(t)<<(t%4<>2]|=128<<(t%4<55)for(r(o,a),t=0;t1&&void 0!==arguments[1]?arguments[1]:{}).modalTimeout,n=arguments[2].clog,r=window.localStorage.getItem(o.HASH_KEY),a=window.localStorage.getItem(o.DATE_KEY),i=new Promise(function(i,c){!function(e){var t=document.createElement(“DIV”);t.className=”modal”,e.appendChild(t),e.classList.add(“skeleton”),e.modal=t}(e),e.modalTimeout=setTimeout(function(){f(e),n(“Timed out getting new version”),c(“TIMEOUT”),n(“TIMEOUT”)},t||u),caches.open(o.CACHE_KEY).then(function(e){e.match(location.href).then(function(e){if(e){var t=e.headers.get(o.HASH_PREFIX),n=e.headers.get(“date”);e.text().then(function(e){r!==t&&Date(n)>Date(a)&&i({content:e,contentHash:t,status:”networkCacheUpdate”,date:n})})}})}),navigator.serviceWorker.addEventListener(“message”,function(e){if(e.origin===location.origin){var t=e.data;if(t&&”NEW_VERSION”===t.message&&t.url===location.href){n(“Updating from sw message”),n(“NETWORK UPDATE”);var r={content:t.content,contentHash:t.contentHash,status:”networkUpdate”,date:t.date};i(r)}}})});return i.then(function(t){n(“GETDATA RESOLVED”),function(e,t){if(window.localStorage.getItem(o.HASH_KEY)!==t.contentHash){var n=document.implementation.createHTMLDocument(“temp”);n.documentElement.innerHTML=t.content,e.parentNode.replaceChild(n.querySelector(“main”),e),f(e);var r=document.createEvent(“HTMLEvents”);r.initEvent(“component.activate”,!0,!0),r.data={},document.querySelector(“main”).dispatchEvent(r),window.localStorage.setItem(o.HASH_KEY,t.contentHash),window.localStorage.setItem(o.DATE_KEY,t.date)}else f(e)}(e,t),n(t.status)}).catch(function(e){n(“GETDATA REJECTED”),n(“Error getting data: “+e)}),i},n.response=function(e,t){var n=arguments.length>2&&void 0!==arguments[2]?arguments[2]:”https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/”,r=arguments[3],a=(arguments.length>4&&void 0!==arguments[4]?arguments[4]:{}).debug,u=e.request.url,f=function(){};a&&(f=function(e){console.log(“[TM PWA] “+e)});var d=u.match(///.+?//)[0].includes(t),h=d&&!u.includes(“service-worker.js”);if((h=function(e,t){for(var n=s.length,r=l.length,o=0;!t&&o<n;)t=s[o].pattern(e),o++;for(o=0;t&&o2&&void 0!==arguments[2]?arguments[2]:”readonly”;return new Promise(function(o,a){var i=e.open(“marwood-pwa”,1);i.onupgradeneeded=function(){r.forEach(function(e){i.result.objectStoreNames.contains(e.name)||i.result.createObjectStore(e.name,{keyPath:e.key})})},i.onsuccess=function(){if(i.result.onversionchange=function(e){null===e.newVersion&&e.target.close()},i&&i.result&&i.result.objectStoreNames.contains(t)){var e=i.result.transaction(t,n).objectStore(t);if(e)return void o(e)}a()}})}},{}],7:[function(e,t,n){“use strict”;Object.defineProperty(n,”__esModule”,{value:!0});var r=”marwood-896d7bb990899be5c1255282bc726a1c”,o=”offline/”;function a(e){caches.open(r).then(function(t){document.querySelectorAll(‘meta[name=”cache-preload”]’).forEach(function(e){var n=e.getAttribute(“content”);t.match(n).then(function(e){e||t.add(n)})});var n=e+o;t.match(n).then(function(e){e||fetch(n).then(function(e){if(e.redirected){var r=e.clone(),o={status:r.status,statusText:r.statusText,headers:{}};e.headers.forEach(function(e,t){o.headers[t]=e}),r.text().then(function(e){t.put(n,new Response(e,o))})}else t.put(n,e)})})})}n.default=function(){var e=arguments.length>0&&void 0!==arguments[0]?arguments[0]:{},t=e.selector,n=e.maxUrls,i=e.endpoint,c=arguments.length>1&&void 0!==arguments[1]?arguments[1]:”https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/”;navigator.serviceWorker.addEventListener(“message”,function(e){e.origin===location.origin&&”SERVICE_WORKER_INSTALL”===e.data&&a(c)}),navigator.onLine&&location.pathname!==c+o&&(a(c),”number”!=typeof n&&(n=10),i||t||(t=”.teaser”),window.addEventListener(“load”,function(){var e=JSON.parse(localStorage.getItem(“offlineUrls”))||[];(function(e,t){var n=e.endpoint,r=e.selector;if(n)return new Promise(function(e){fetch(n+”?url=”+location.href.split(“?”)[0]).then(function(n){n.json().then(function(n){e(n.filter(function(e){return e.url&&e.url.length>0}).slice(0,t).map(function(e){return{url:e.url,text:e.title,image:e.image.href.replace(“/BINARY/”,”/alternates/s615b/”),tag:e.tags&&e.tags[0]}}))})})});if(r){var o=Array.from(document.querySelectorAll(r)).slice(0,t);return Promise.resolve(o.map(function(e){var t=e.querySelector(“a.headline”),n=e.querySelector(“img”),r=e.querySelector(“a.label”);return{url:t&&t.getAttribute(“href”),text:t&&t.innerHTML,image:n&&n.getAttribute(“data-src”)||n.getAttribute(“src”),tag:r&&r.innerHTML}}))}})({endpoint:i,selector:t},n).then(function(t){var o=t;e.length&&(o=t.filter(function(t){return e.find(function(e){return t.url!==e.url})})),o.length&&caches.open(r).then(function(t){o.forEach(function(r){r.text&&r.url&&r.image&&t.addAll([r.url,r.image]).then(function(){e.find(function(e){return e.url===r.url})||e.unshift(r),e.length>n&&e.pop(),localStorage.setItem(“offlineUrls”,JSON.stringify(e))})})})})}))}},{}],8:[function(e,t,n){“use strict”;Object.defineProperty(n,”__esModule”,{value:!0}),n.track=function(e,t){(0,a.default)(e,i,”readwrite”).then(function(e){e.put({url:t,timestamp:(new Date).getTime()})})},n.offlineLandingTracking=function(){var e=localStorage.getItem(c);return localStorage.removeItem(c),e},n.trackOfflineLanding=function(){localStorage.setItem(c,Number(localStorage.getItem(c)||0)+1)};var r,o=e(6),a=(r=o)&&r.__esModule?r:{default:r};var i=”pageviews”,c=”offlineLandingPageViews”;n.default=function(e,t){(0,a.default)(e,i,”readwrite”).then(function(e){var n=e.count();n.onsuccess=function(){var r=n.result-1;r>0&&t(r),e.clear()}})}},{6:6}],9:[function(e,t,n){“use strict”;Object.defineProperty(n,”__esModule”,{value:!0}),n.MANIFEST_CACHE_NAME=n.validate=n.urlBase64ToUint8Array=n.cookie=n.getManifest=n.analytics=void 0,n.stub=function(e){var t={analytics:h,getManifest:m};return n.analytics=h=e.stub(),n.getManifest=m=e.stub(),{analytics:h,getManifest:m,restore:function(){n.analytics=h=t.analytics,n.getManifest=m=t.getManifest}}};var r=e(8),o=l(r),a=l(e(4)),i=l(e(1)),c=l(e(7)),u=l(e(5)),s=e(10);function l(e){return e&&e.__esModule?e:{default:e}}var f=navigator.userAgent.match(/iPhone|iPad|iPod/i);function d(e,t){var n=t.clog;i.default.fire(window,”contentupdate”,e),n(“CONTENTUPDATE: “+e)}function h(e){var t=arguments.length>1&&void 0!==arguments[1]?arguments[1]:1;i.default.fire(window,”analytics.track”,{name:e,category:”metrics”,value:t})}function g(e,t,n){var r=n.clog,o=window.localStorage.getItem(s.HASH_KEY);(0,a.default)(e,t.cacheFirst,{clog:r}).then(function(e){d(o===e.contentHash?”unchanged”:”fresh”,{clog:r}),h(“cacheFirstPageView”)}).catch(function(){d(“cached”,{clog:r}),h(“cacheFirstPageView”),r(“CACHED PAGE VIEW”),navigator.serviceWorker.addEventListener(“message”,function(e){if(e.origin===location.origin){var t=e.data;t&&”NEW_VERSION”===t.message&&t.url===location.href&&(o!==t.contentHash?(h(“stalePageView”),r(“STALE PAGE VIEW”)):(h(“cachedPageView”),r(“MOULDY PAGE VIEW”)))}})})}function v(e){return encodeURIComponent(e||””)}function m(){var e=arguments.length>0&&void 0!==arguments[0]?arguments[0]:””,t=arguments[1],n=document.querySelector(“link[rel=manifest]”);if(n){var r=t||n.href;return new Promise(function(t,n){caches.open(s.MANIFEST_CACHE_NAME+”:”+e).then(function(e){e.match(r).then(function(n){n?t(n):fetch(r).then(function(n){e.put(r,n.clone()),t(n.clone())})})}).catch(function(e){return n(e)})}).then(function(e){return e.json().then(function(e){return e})})}}n.default=function(e,t,n){var a=function(){};if(“serviceWorker”in navigator){try{e=JSON.parse(e)}catch(t){e=e||{}}if(!e.debug)try{e.debug=new URLSearchParams(window.location.search).get(“pwaDebug”)}catch(e){}(0,u.default)(window.indexedDB,e,n);var s=”/service-worker.js?v=4bd35006110c8b784c81b089f61238e9″;e.debug&&(s+=”&pwaDebug=”+e.debug,a=function(e){window.console.log(“[TM PWA] “+e)}),e.cacheFirst&&(s+=”&cacheFirst=true”),e.offlineSupport&&(s+=”&offlineSupport=true”),t&&(s=s+”&pushDisplayService=”+t+”&vap=”+v(n.vapidKey)+”&a=”+v(n.appKey)+”&t=”+v(n.token)+”&i=”+v());var l=void 0;if(e.scope&&(l={scope:e.scope}),window.sessionStorage.setItem(“swUrl”,s),navigator.serviceWorker.register(s,l).then(function(){a(“Service worker registered successfully”);var e=”n !function (n, t, c, e, u) { n function r(n) { try { f = n(u) } catch (n) { return h = n, void i(p, n) } i(s, f) } n function i(n, t) { for (var c = 0; c 2&&void 0!==arguments[2]?arguments[2]:2,r=new Date;r.setTime(r.getTime()+24*n*60*60*1e3),document.cookie=e+”=”+t+”;expires=”+r.toUTCString()+”;path=/”},n.urlBase64ToUint8Array=s.urlBase64ToUint8Array,n.validate=function(e,t){var n=t||””;if(!e)return{homepage:n};var r=void 0;try{r=JSON.parse(document.getElementById(“manifest-validation”).getAttribute(“content”))}catch(e){return null}var o=e.filter(function(e){return r.url&&r.url.includes(e.homepage)}),a=e.filter(function(e){return r.primaryTag&&r.primaryTag===e.tag}),i=e.filter(function(e){return r.tags&&r.tags.includes(e.tag)});if(1===o.length)return o[0];if(1===a.length)return a[0];if(1===i.length)return i[0];var c=e.filter(function(e){return e.scope===n});return c.length>0?c[0]:”string”==typeof t?{homepage:t}:void 0},n.MANIFEST_CACHE_NAME=s.MANIFEST_CACHE_NAME},{1:1,10:10,4:4,5:5,7:7,8:8}],10:[function(e,t,n){“use strict”;Object.defineProperty(n,”__esModule”,{value:!0});var r=/(.*/amp/.*|.*.amp)/g,o=”TM-Hash-“+location.href,a=”TM-Date-“+location.href;n.CACHE_KEY=”marwood-896d7bb990899be5c1255282bc726a1c”,n.CACHE_NAME=”marwood”,n.MANIFEST_CACHE_NAME=”manifestCache”,n.urlBase64ToUint8Array=function(e){for(var t=(e+”=”.repeat((4-e.length%4)%4)).replace(/-/g,”+”).replace(/_/g,”https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/”),n=atob(t),r=new Uint8Array(n.length),o=0;o<n.length;++o)r[o]=n.charCodeAt(o);return r},n.isAmpArticle=function(e){return e.match(r)},n.HASH_PREFIX="TM-Hash",n.HASH_KEY=o,n.DATE_KEY=a,n.PUSH_SERVICE_KEY="airship",n.PUSH_SERVICE_SCRIPT="https://aswpsdkus.com/notify/v1/ua-sdk.min.js",n.getAssetUrl=function(e){return e&&e.replace?e.replace("prod",function(e){return/-bertha./.test(e)?"bertha":/-stable./.test(e)?"stable":"prod"}(self.location)):e},n.path=function(e,t){if(e&&t){var n=e.split?e.split("."):e;if(n.reduce)return n.reduce(function(e,t){return e&&e[t]?e[t]:void 0},t)}},n.externalDebug=function(e,t){t&&localStorage.removeItem("airship");var n=JSON.parse(localStorage.getItem("airship")||"[]");e.length&&n.push(e),localStorage.setItem("airship",JSON.stringify(n))}},{}]},{},[3]);
//# sourceMappingURL=pwa.min.js.map


Disclaimer- This content is from the following URl. If the content is not loading properly then please click the button below and read the full article.

x